Monday, July 6, 2020

Out of Your Mind: Tricksters, Interdependence, and the Cosmic Game of Hide and Seek

Inside of five minutes with this book, Alan Watts gave voice to one of the inherent contradictions within me – I am both goo and prickly, it seems. Scientific terms, clearly. Watts states early, and somewhat often, that there are two kinds of philosophy – goo and prickles, with prickly people liking precision and logic (yes, please!) and goo people liking things vague. I’m generally not in favor of the vague…..but wait, goo people are also idealists, and how many times have I been asked in my life how I could be both an idealist and such a structured realist? My mind’s eye could see the location and context for that very exchange with a colleague not more than two years ago. Egads. And so it is that I was forced to wonder yet again how Watts could understand what made me tick.

Perhaps most revelatory was the way in which Out of Your Mind made me (re)consider myself. Specifically, although I would long agree with the assertion that I am smart, perhaps, depending on the topic, even wicked smart, I would never have agreed with the statement that I was in any way a deep thinker or philosophizer. I have always held the butterfly effect as a self-evident truth, and so to see Watts argue for the same idea as a type of philosophy (“if a given star out in the universe didn’t exist, you would be different from who you are now”) was startling. This is not, it seems, a given for all. Likewise, although I have tried six ways to Sunday, I know with every fiber of my being that there is pure veracity in the succinct assertion that you “can’t love on purpose.” Seeing so many of my beliefs printed in black and white by a man known for the quality of his thoughts, I am reconsidering whether the various friends who lean on me for advice might know something about me that I did not.

Watts also provided the anecdote that largely solves for me one on the enduring mysteries of self I’ve never understood. For many, many years, Americans and foreigners alike have proclaimed me “not really American.” Given that I have tendencies to be opinionated, forthright, loquacious, and often a bit loud, I’ve never quite understood…and no one has ever provided me a satisfactory response. Watts, though, ah, he has given me a response. For he writes of the Zen koans for exploring questions like, “if your parents never met, would you be here? If your parents met other people and had children, would one of those children be you?” And questions like these, well these are simply my favorite rabbit holes of all time. Since no one else I know falls down the same holes, I figured I was just weird or crazy (or both), but then to see in print that this is actually a thing….the lightbulb went off and I finally understood why so many people have declared me not really American. Closer to home, this one anecdote illuminated why life at home was such a challenge: he cannot stand when I ponder such questions, but such musings are an inherent part of my nature. Suppressed or explored, one of us always felt the tension. Or, as Watts writes elsewhere, “people who are interesting are people who are interested.” (Touché?)

When I read that we spend an awful lot of energy trying to make our lives fit images or what life is or should be, I nearly cried: would that someone had prepared me for that reality 20 years ago. Likewise, when Watts asks “who said you could get the better of life,” I was dumbstruck by the simplicity of a notion I have spent most of my adulthood fighting – you can’t outwit the universe. And although it’s easy to wish I had known and understood these pearls of wisdom years ago, I am wise enough now to appreciate that only the present is real, and grateful that I’ve figured this out at 40 rather than 80.

For many years, I was too focused on the front of the embroidery – that neat, tidy picture, to consider how the back of the embroidery was eating away at me. As Watts might say, the messiness required for the beautiful picture was a game not worth the candle. My one disagreement with him, though was where he urged his reader not to be caught looking at the back of the embroidery. It seems to me that such close examination – of a duration such that one is almost sure to be caught – is a necessary precursor to being able to “claim your life and proclaim with gusto, ‘I’m responsible.’” For, yes, I had created the beautiful embroidery, but it wasn’t until I was willing to take ownership of the mess underneath that I could even begin to extract myself from it….even at the cost of unmaking a goodly chunk of that beautiful and much-admired image on the front.

And when you’ve a lot of messiness underneath your life, regardless of whether others see it or know that it’s there, it’s hard to have fun. I laughed out loud when I read that “people get terribly compulsive doing things they think they have to do” because that revelation, for me was the revelation that set me on a new path. I needn’t divulge all the gory details here, but suffice it to say, from setting a quota on the number of books to be read in a year; to miles to be run, swum, or biked; to calories to be consumed (or not), I’ve known my share of compulsions. All have one thing in common: they suck the fun out of whatever activity is in play, so that each new outlet becomes a new chore, one more task to be marked off the long list of daily activities.

Watts writes that to spread joy, you need to have joy, and that is the emotion that leaks from each page. Out of Your Mind is not written to be humorous, but again and it again, Watts’s approach filled me with warmth and appreciation. He’s not advocating “being flabby.” It’s “taboo to scream in a hospital.” (Someone should have told me before I did just that the last time I was in one. Admittedly, through the fog of many sedatives I did notice mine were the only shrieks rending the air.)

It was his closing that seared me though. “When you discover that there is nothing to cling to and there isn’t anybody to cling to them, everything is quite different. … You feel almost that you are walking on air.” In case anyone is confused, America is a bit of a dumpster fire these days. And yet, personally, I’ve never felt lighter or happier. This feels like a dangerous admission, but I somehow feel Watts would understand. 

Five stars.

No comments:

Post a Comment